It might be one of the oldest questions on the web (surely the topic of some long-running flame wars), but I’m curious, so I’m asking: What Content Management System do you use?
Some backstory: I’ve recently begun working at a New York-based web design and Internet marketing firm as their all-around design/development guy, and a big part of what I’m bringing to the company is expertise outside of Flash-based development (which is really common in the industry for which my company does work), and some really old-school Dreamweaver-generated table-based designs.
I’m there to push CSS, standards-based stuff, flexibility, and implement solutions that push the industry forward in terms of accessibility, usability, and efficiency. It’s an uphill climb, to be sure (can you climb downwardly?), but one that is fulfilling, and for which noticeable progress is already being made. In a way, I’m as much a consultant as a site-builder, and that suits me just fine.
Now, one thing I’ve been trying to figure out is how best to approach issues of content management for our clients, particularly new ones.
The way I see it, there are several different possibilities:
- Having the client (or content manager) purchase and use commercial CMS software like Adobe Contribute or Dreamweaver.
- Purchasing and installing a web-based CMS (something PHP-y, ideally, since I’m capable with that).
- Using Wordpress, Drupal, or similar open-source Content Management Systems.
- Building a custom CMS from the ground up.
- Implementing services like the new CushyCMS, which is a totally hosted content management service that now offers a premium version for designers that allows you to create a branded CMS and bill clients monthly, if desired.
- Award all clients a complimentary copy of HTML For Dummies upon completion of their site and change the office phone numbers.
- I’m inclined to hate Dreamweaver and Contribute (I think they violate my religion, perhaps). And I think there’s a great deal to be said about the ability to update one’s site from anywhere with an internet connection - without having to install expensive software.
- Non-free web-based CMSes: I know they exist, but I don’t know which ones are good. Why use these rather than their free counterparts?
- I’ve used Wordpress in the (recent) past for client sites, and I like it enough, but it doesn’t seem meant to handle “real websites.” I don’t mean this as an attack on its particular technical merits (though the Digg crowd surely does), but merely as a comment on what I gather to be its “software worldview,” if I may coin a phrase with only 283 results in Google.
- I have yet to use Drupal, though I’ve been researching it, and it seems viable.
- We don’t have the capabilities in-house to develop custom Content Management Systems aside from very exceptional cases for which we can have a pretty cool Rails developer to put something together for us, so that’s pretty much out, and beyond the financial abilities of most of our clients, besides.
- And CushyCMS intrigues me, and seems really great for smaller clients, but the idea of relying on third-party hosting scares me a little. How do you tell your clients, “There’s nothing we can do about it?”
Let me know in the comments!


8 comments:
Hi,
we use Kentico CMS, the content management system for ASP.NET. Unfortunately this solution is not for free but I think it is worth every $ :-).
We are very happy with it since it is powerful and flexible system. We purchased the license with the full source code and it allows us to modify Kentico.
I have to mention one thing. If you use some free solution you could have a lot of troubles without professional support. So I recommend you to purchase the solution with the support. We are really satisfied with Kentico support. Guys from Kentico are excellent ;-).
Guy from cushycms here...
Just to clarify- all your client's files are still hosted on their servers.
So in the unlikely event our service goes down it wont affect your clients sites, just their ability to edit the content.
Thanks!
Thanks for the clarification, Guy. I see know that I didn't make a clear distinction between the content remaining online and the ability to edit it... CushyCMS is definitely several steps above 100%-hosted solutions like Blogger, Wordpress.com, etc., when it comes to this control.
If you are good with css/xhtml as you are, go for Textpattern. I've been using it for a year now, and the more I use it, the more I like it.
Support is great at the txp forum, lots of great plugin, and if you know php you could easily write your own plugin and expand it for your needs.
Cheers!
Andrija,
Thanks for the suggestion. Textpattern looks really great. I'm definitely going to give it a spin.
If I were to trust my former colleague who designed my former employer's site, I must say that we used MODx with our head bowed in shame. I just wrote all the pretty articles, updated all the links and uploaded images and audio using it, but he used to jokingly tell me that my prowess on it was not something to be proud of. :-) It was dummy-proof enough for me though!
How ya been??
I miss cyberspace. Earth is boring.
Cheers from your friend in Orlando who needs to change jobs but can't just yet!
Choosing right CMS is not tricky at all. I use Wordpress for blogs and Instant Update for my clients.
I have used and chopped up Wordpress and agree it only works for certain types of sites. I am attempting my first Drupal site this month, using HTML/CSS completely from us and dropping in Drupal when necessary. It's nice to know you don't have to start with a Drupal template and edit it - but that you can go the other way too.
Post a Comment